I need help deciding on a car

Okay here is the info. I like all of these and have test driven them. Matt really likes the calibur because of the price and we won't have to pay that much per month. I, of course, like the most expensive one! But it is also cheaper through insurance and our interest rate on the car loan will go down because it is a new car. Here compare this information and leave me comments:

2008 DODGE CALIBER SXT 1B3HB48B68D673679

SEDAN 4 DR 2.0L L4 DOHC 16V FRONT WHEEL DRIVE 5 speed automatic

Mileage: 20, 900

Price: 10

Insurance: -52.93 lower a month and new premium of 850.90 / 6 months

Insurance Payments: 141. 82 for both per month

Current asking price: 14,000-23,350

Safety: Motortrend-still testing, none reported

NHTSA- out of five

Frontal Driver Rating Frontal Passenger Rating Side Driver Rating Side Rear Passenger Rating Rollover 2 Wheel Drive Rating Rollover 4 Wheel Drive Rating 5 5 5 5 4 Not tested

2009 DODGE JOURNEY SXT 3D4GG57V29T159419

4 DR. WAGON/SPORT UTILITY 3.5L V6 MPI SOHC 24V FRONT WHEEL DRIVE

19" ALLOY WHEELS, POWER SEAT, 6CD CHANGER/MP3 PLAYER, AUX INPUT, SIRIUS RADIO, POWER LOCKS/WINDOWS, CRUISE, SIDE AIRBAGS, STILL UNDER BUMPER TO BUMPER FACTORY WARRANTY, FINANCING AVAILABLE, TRADES ACCEPTED, CARFAX CERTIFIED, NO DEALER FEES 6 Speed automatic

Mileage: 7,056

Price: 15, 990

Insurance: -87.14 every six months for new premium of 816.68 for 6 months

Insurance Payments: 136.12 for both per month

Current asking price: 23,000-25,755

Safety: Motortrend-being tested, none reported

NHTSA- out of five

Frontal Driver Rating	Frontal Passenger Rating	Side Driver Rating	Side Rear Passenger Rating	Rollover 2 Wheel Drive Rating	Rollover 4 Wheel Drive Rating
5	5	5	5	4	4

2008 JEEP COMPASS SPORT 1J8FT47WX8D720048 4 DR. WAGON/SPORT UTILITY 2.4L I4 SFI DOHC REAR WHEEL DRIVE Sunroof 5 Speed automatic 17" ALLOY WHEELS, AUTOSTICK, 6CD CHANGER/MP3, POWER LOCKS/WINDOWS, CRUISE, SUNROOF, SIDE AIRBAGS, STILL UNDER BUMPER TO BUMPER FACTORY WARRANTY, FINANCING AVAILABLE, TRADES ACCEPTED, CARFAX CERTIFIED, NO DEALER FEES

Mileage: 7,399

Price: 14, 990

Insurance: -81.06 lower with a new 6 month premium of 822.76

Insurance Payments: 137.13 for both per month

Current asking price: 18,000-24,575

Safety: Motortrend- no information

NHTSA- out of five

Frontal Driver Rating	Frontal Passenger Rating	Side Driver Rating	Side Rear Passenger Rating	Rollover 2 Wheel Drive Rating	Rollover 4 Wheel Drive Rating